News

A council worker who protested against the use of woke pronouns has been hit with a £12,000 legal bill.

A council worker who protested against the use of woke pronouns has been hit with a £12,000 legal bill.

Jim Orwin lost his job when he refused to use ‘acceptable’ pronouns such as he/him and instead used the words ‘XYchromosomeGuy/AdultHumanMale’ to the end of his emails.

The ICT project officer was suspended and eventually sacked by East Riding of Yorkshire Council in 2022 when he refused to change the sign-off.

In May he took the authority to a tribunal, saying they had discriminated against his beliefs and he had been unfairly dismissed as if he had remained silent he would have ‘facilitated the steady creep of evil’.

Although the panel dismissed his case and found he was not discriminated against, it did accept his gender-critical beliefs amounted to a protected ‘philosophical belief within the meaning of section 10 of the Equality Act 2010’.

But now Mr Orwin has forced to pay the council £12,000 after an employment judge ruled his tribunal claim was ‘vexatious’.

The row started when an email was sent out to all staff by East Riding of Yorkshire Council’s chief executive Caroline Lacey in April 2022, urging them to ‘consider adding pronouns’ to their emails.

Staff were told that it was an ‘individual choice’ and were given links to websites which offered explanations as to why such words could be used.

The tribunal heard the reason for bringing in the policy was to ‘promote inclusion of people who identify their gender in a way that is not necessarily consistent with their biological 𝑠e𝑥’.

However, after receiving the email, Mr Orwin ‘quickly formed the view’ it had been done to ‘facilitate self-identification.’

He told the hearing: ‘Had the email contained a genuine invitation simply for colleagues to add pronouns to email signatures and not facilitated self-identification I would have chosen the ‘Do not show’ option not to display pronouns.

‘It is my firm belief that announcing pronouns in emails or before meetings is a political gesture designed to intimidate anyone who does not embrace the contested ideology of gender identity.’

He ‘interpreted’ the email to allow employees to add their own pronouns rather than having to choose from a list.

Therefore, he decided to add the words ‘XYchromosomeGuy/AdultHumanMale’ and following this he contacted his manager to give him ‘advanced notice’.

When he was asked why he simply couldn’t choose the ‘other’ option of pronouns, Mr Orwin said: ‘Not adding a pronoun would be accepting this garbage and is not an option I can choose.’

The tribunal heard how Mr Orwin thought the only way to challenge the policy was to ‘adopt deliberately provocative pronouns’.

However, he was told his choices were unacceptable as they ‘may be deemed offensive to others’.

He carried on defying orders to remove them, claiming it was ‘unlawful discrimination’ and in August 2022 was summoned to a disciplinary hearing.

He said he wouldn’t back down as it was ‘all about principles’ and was sacked.

Mr Orwin, from Hull, said that four different employment judges dealt with the various stages of the tribunal process and that it was never suggested that his claim was vexatious.

He said: ‘Not one of the judges, nor the Council’s legal team, so much as suggested that possibility. The word was never mentioned.

‘The first suggestion that my claim might be considered vexatious was in the Council’s recent costs application. I understand that it is not unusual for employers who succeed in defending claims in the employment tribunal to submit a costs application, but the general principle in employment tribunals is that each party is responsible for its own legal costs. In his costs order, the judge said I pursued the case because I found the concept of gender self-identification objectionable, which I think any reasonable person would consider to be entirely consistent with holding gender-critical beliefs, and therefore not vexatious at all.

‘Those who share gender-critical beliefs must be able to bring legitimate claims of belief discrimination to the Employment Tribunal without the threat of sanctions being imposed on them simply because of their protected beliefs.

‘I think in the current climate, most of the British public will see this costs order judgment as yet another example of a two-tier judiciary, and somewhat inconsistent with the Employment Tribunal’s duty of political impartiality.’

The tribunal found Mr Orwin’s ‘gender-critical belief’ constitutes a ‘philosophical belief’.

However, Employment Judge Ian Miller concluded he had not been discriminated against by being told to change his pronouns.

He said: ‘The real reason that [Mr Orwin] decided to add ‘XY-chromosome-guy/adult-human-male’ was in protest.’

Mr Miller added: ‘The footer was designed to provoke and, we think given his acceptance of possible offence, was designed to offend.’

The judge said the implementation of the policy was ‘poorly thought through and badly executed’.

Dismissing his claims of discrimination, he said: ‘None of the treatment he experienced was because of his beliefs (or expression of beliefs).

His claim of unfair dismissal was also dismissed as it was ‘well within the band of reasonable responses of a reasonable employer’.

Awarding costs, the judge found that Mr Orwin pursued the claim ‘solely’ because he ‘found objectionable both the concept of gender self-identification and the council’s decision to adopt a policy that indicated they believed the ideology of gender self-identification to be valid.’

Mr Orwin has now launched a crowdfunding bid to raise the cash for the council’s costs.

East Riding of Yorkshire Council has been approached for comment.

Related Posts

Conor McGregor vows ‘big actions are coming’ and says he is ‘soon to be vindicated’ as he launches furious tirade against his rape accuser Nikita Hand after she won €250,000 from him in court

Conor McGregor has warned ‘big actions are coming’ and he is ‘soon to be vindicated’ during a series of social media tirades against a decision to award his rape accuser nearly €250,000. McGregor, 36, was found by a jury in a civil court to have 𝑠e𝑥ually assaulted Nikita Hand, 35, at a hotel in south Dublin in December 2018. After deliberating for six hours and 10 minutes, a jury of eight women and four men returned their verdict on Friday afternoon, awarding Ms Hand the substantial damages for her claim.

Bombshell new clue may finally crack DB Cooper case 53 years after hijacker escaped out of plane with $200k

The parachute that the infamous hijacker DB Cooper used to make his getaway out of a plane with $200,000 may have finally been found. The enigma behind DB Cooper, the man who jumped out of Northwest Orient Airlines Flight 305 with thousands in cash after handing a stewardess a note demanding the ransom, has long stumped the FBI. Nearly a decade later, the FBI has begun unofficially looking back into the case after the children of Richard Floyd McCoy II contacted YouTuber Dan Gryder in 2020 with possible evidence.

‘Never-Trump’ columnist ridiculed for calling Trump’s Cabinet ‘1,000 shades of white’

Washington Post columnist Jennifer Rubin is being ridiculed for calling Donald Trump’s cabinet nominations ‘1,000 shades of white’. Rubin, 62, a former conservative commentator at the Jeff Bezos-owned paper, now largely advocates for Democrats and on her podcast, ‘Jen Rubin’s Green Room.’ Speaking on MSNBC Rubin did not hold back as she ripped Trump’s nominations over the color of their skin.

Matt Gaetz is mercilessly mocked over surprising new career move: ‘Not on my bingo card’

Former Attorney General pick Matt Gaetz has turned his eyes towards a new career after claiming he was forced to exit Congress due to a 𝑠e𝑥 ‘smear’ campaign. Gaetz, sensationally dropped out of contention two days ago amid a sleuth of allegations including having 𝑠e𝑥 with a minor girl and and illicit drug use – which he has always denied. He also withdrew himself from Congress for next year despite having been re-elected to the seat he vacated.

Mass job losses as major factory owner moves business overseas

A major New York tire factory that has operated for over a century is set to close after its executives moved its manufacturing overseas. Sumitomo Rubber USA, which owns tire maker Dunlop, fired 1,550 people this week as the Japanese company plans to close its Buffalo factory. The company did not announce plans at the same time to open a new factory, but said it made the ‘difficult decision’ because the New York manufacturer couldn’t keep up with overseas prices.

Crushing blow for Anthony Albanese as hugely controversial misinformation bill is SCRAPPED

Communications minister Michelle Rowland has announced Labor will abandon its push to introduce a misinformation Bill. Ms Rowland made the announcement on Sunday following revelations the Greens, Coalition and several crossbenchers would not support the legislation. ‘Based on public statements and engagements with senators, it is clear that there is no pathway to legislate this proposal through the Senate,’ she said in a statement.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *