“Taylor Swift wearing a Jeff Hamilton off white Wool & Leather Kansas City Chiefs jacket for the victory of the @chiefs vs the @bengals today,” Hamilton wrote over footage shared on Instagram of Swift arriving at the New Year’s Eve game.

Kelce, also 34, later dropped by in the comments to hype up the post, sharing a few fire emojis and some double high-fives, along with a like. His nod to Swift then received over 3,000 likes from fans and even a comment to him asking, “can you tell Taylor Swift I love her.”

JEFF HAMILTON INSTAGRAM

Swift’s jacket matched his own Kansas City Chiefs jacket that he wore on Christmas day — along with a Santa hat — while leaving the locker room after his game against the Las Vegas Raiders. The “Karma” singer’s version included a few special touches, including a cursive “Tay-Tay” embroidered next to one of the pockets.

Swift cheered and danced throughout the game, and the Chiefs wound up defeating the Cincinnati Bengals 25-17 to secure the AFC West division title — a huge win after several up-and-down weeks as the season wraps up. The Super Bowl 2023 MVP and the pop superstar then left the game together, as captured by The Kansas City Star journalist Nick Wagner, who shared his photo on Instagram.

Later on Sunday, Swift and the tight end were spotted sharing a kiss while ringing in 2024. The quick flash of footage captured at a Kansas City party was shared by an onlooker on social media.

Glamming up for the night, Swift had changed from her special sporty coat into a sparkly minidress with stars and moon hair accessories, while Kelce rocked a maroon suit. Swift’s dress appeared to be by Clio Peppiatt, the same designer behind her 34th birthday dress, per Taylor Swift Style, a fan-run style blog on the singer.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Doubling down this holiday season, the couple spent Christmas Day together as well, with Swift cheering on Kelce from the stands as his team took on the Las Vegas Raiders.

For the special Christmas game, Swift brought along her entire family, including her parents Scott and Andrea Swift, and her younger brother Austin, who dressed up as Santa for the festive match-up.